top of page

The Quest for Intention in Art

Nov 8
15 min read

Updated: 3 days ago

Artelier examines what speed has done to art. A $69 million JPEG, sixty galleries closed in a single year, marketplaces flooded with images: reflecting on art history – Warhol’s supermarket, Picasso’s circle of dealers and rivals – our curator makes the case for the slower pleasures, for expertise, for conversation, and for the deeply human business of being with art.



Andy Warhol choosing Campbell’s soup at Gristede’s, New York, 1964 – two years after he painted the thirty-two cans. Photo: Bob Adelman
Andy Warhol choosing Campbell’s soup at Gristede’s, New York, 1964 – two years after he painted the thirty-two cans. Photo: Bob Adelman


Index

  1. The Next Big Thing (Hype)

  2. Before Influencers (Reputation)

  3. It’s a Pop Art’s World (Consumerism)

  4. The Soup (Saturation)

  5. Curatorship: Handle With Care (Judgement)

  6. Being With Art (Intention)




Introduction


Throughout the past few years, Artelier's curators have become increasingly aware of the saturated image-marketplace: generative tools have arrived, AI art services and images surround us at every level: on our phones, on our commute, in the few minutes before sleep.


The trouble with the fast and the highly consumable is that quality gets left by the wayside. What happens to the artist who devotes a lifetime to their craft and must now compress it into an Instagram-ready 4:5 crop in the hope of being funded? Or to the sixty galleries that closed in 2025 squeezed out by the costs of staying in the game, no longer able to steward the artists they had championed? What we choose to preserve is, in the end, what a culture becomes.


This essay is an evolution of an earlier 2023 essay, The Quest for Originality in Art, which looked at the dilution of artworks when the feed rewards imitation. Three years later, times have changed, and so has the question: this is less a quest for originality than a quest for intention. We have looked for answers partly in art history: in Picasso’s studio, in Pop’s argument with consumerism, and in the dealers and patrons who built reputations one conversation at a time. Here at Artelier, we are in it for the long haul; and so, in our experience, are the artists worth knowing.



The Next Big Thing



Beeple moniker for artist Mike Winkelmann, Everydays: The First 5000 Days (2007–2021), digital artwork sold as an NFT at Christie’s for $69.3 million in 2021.
Beeple moniker for artist Mike Winkelmann, Everydays: The First 5000 Days (2007–2021), digital artwork sold as an NFT at Christie’s for $69.3 million in 2021.

In times of great technological advancements, it's no easy feat to resist the seduction of the newest and glossiest Next Big Thing. It's hardly surprising that NFTs, which took the art world by storm in 2021, enticed new buyers seeking the unicorn of art-investment returns. NFTs can appear slick, highly contemporary and fairly complex to comprehend (esoteric, even) – all the makings of an emerging asset class that savvy investors would want to get in on quick and early. But was it all it was cracked up to be?


Beeple, Everydays: The First 5000 Days (2007-2021), final artwork of 5000
Beeple, Everydays: The First 5000 Days (2007-2021), final artwork of 5000

Beeple’s Everydays: The First 5000 Days is the most compelling example. A collage of 5,000 images, one made every day for thirteen years, it begins with a crude pencil drawing of his Uncle Jim and ends in dense, luridly coloured dystopias where alien forms of Donald Trump, Kim Jong-Un, Buzz Lightyear and a Hulk-ish Mickey Mouse loiter surreally, like figures from a bad dream. All of it held, in the end, in a single JPEG, owned through a code on a blockchain.

When it went to auction at Christie’s in March 2021 the price went stratospheric. The hammer fell at $69,346,250 to Vignesh Sundaresan, a Singapore-based crypto entrepreneur who bought it through a crypto investment fund. Overnight, Beeple had the third-highest auction price ever paid for a work by a living artist.


It would be easy, and unfair, to call this a cynical exercise, or to conclude that NFTs are silly, faddy or worthless. Sundaresan has spoken about wanting to change how the world engages with art, and says he has no intention of selling. The technology is also helpful for artists: Beeple earns 10% of every future resale, automatically, a better deal than artists get almost anywhere else. The problem was that nothing about the sale moved at the speed that judgement requires. Reputations and movements are usually built slowly, by people who look hard, disagree in public, and revise their minds over years. Here, a price arrived first and everything else had to catch up with it.


And price alone makes a poor verdict. Christie’s opened a dedicated Digital Art and NFTs department in 2022 and by 2023 95% of NFT collections were worth effectively nothing, leaving an estimated 23 million holders with a pittance. In 2025, the department closed. Beeple, meanwhile, is still posting an image a day, as he has since 2007, the one part of this story that isn’t hurried.


Which brings us back to what buying art is for. Anyone can save that JPEG to their desktop in a second; and only one person holds the token that says it is theirs. When all is said and done, how much can be said for buying an artwork that you can’t see? Stand in front of? Be with? In our brief human existence, isn’t this aspirational – to buy art that resonates deeply? True patronage, and works produced to be a joy for ever, rather than one to sell as quickly as possible. One is reminded of Keats’s line:



A thing of beauty is a joy for ever:

Its loveliness increases; it will never

Pass into nothingness; but still will keep

A bower quiet for us, and a sleep

Full of sweet dreams


– John Keats, from Endymion (1818) [abridged]





Before Influencers


So the pull towards recognition, towards making a living, towards having the work taken seriously, is entirely legitimate and it makes sense why artists (like so many of us) are attempting to appeal to the mass-market through technology and content. Yet there is the risk of tipping into gimmick, like the NFT market did. The reality is that what lasts tends to be built by people, slowly, and there is no better place to see it than with the most successful visual artist of the twentieth century.


Picasso is the archetypal genius of modern art, and he was also the most photographed artist of the twentieth century (Gagosian). If any career ought to look like hype, it is this one. The stream of visual culture around him – photographs, experimentations – drew him close to mythic status, and it was largely very intentional: Picasso chose his photographers, controlled access to the studio, and told his close friend, photographer and chronicler Brassaï that he wanted to leave “as complete a record as possible for posterity”. In one sense, he was an influencer half a century before the word existed.


But look at what the camera was pointed at. In May 1937, Picasso began a mural for the Spanish Pavilion in Paris. Christian Zervos, founder of Cahiers d’art and his publisher for a decade, recognised the importance of what Picasso was making and asked Dora Maar to photograph it. Over May and June she made twenty-eight images of Guernica as it metamorphosed: figures painted then left out, the composition shifting, the early narrative clarity giving way to the symbolic.


Zervos published them that year, in a special issue of Cahiers d’art devoted to the painting, alongside essays by Éluard, Leiris and others arguing about it's prominence. The photographs are now held by the Museo Reina Sofía, in the same building as the painting. Maar's pictures survive because of the artists process, a photographer and a magazine who put it in front of people who would consider it deeply.


Dora Maar, The Evolution of “Guernica” by Picasso, (May-June, Paris, 1937) Gelatin silver print on paper. © Museo Reina Sofia
Dora Maar, The Evolution of “Guernica” by Picasso, (May-June, Paris, 1937) Gelatin silver print on paper. © Museo Reina Sofia

The legend of Picasso wasn't built alone; it was built by a community of artists and critics who engaged with what the work meant. Gertrude Stein bought his work when it was little valued and supported him throughout his career, the dealer Kahnweiler took him on in 1907 at a risk, early in his career, and other artists like Matisse and Braque argued (sometimes savagely) over whether any of it was any good. Picasso’s celebrity was built by individuals rather than by a zeitgeist, and the conversation kept returning to the work.


Which is why a gallery could later fill a show with the by-products of his career: Gagosian’s blockbuster Picasso and the Camera (2014) in New York hung 225 photographs alongside some 90 paintings and drawings of Picasso's. A near century later, they still repay looking at because they are inseparable from the practice that produced them and from the people who thought that practice worth preserving. Attention, in other words, was evidence of a life dedicated to practice.


Installation view, Picasso and the Camera, Gagosian (2014). Photo: Rob McKeever.
Installation view, Picasso and the Camera, Gagosian (2014). Photo: Rob McKeever.



It’s a Pop Art’s World



Picasso’s world had not yet been flooded with imagery, nor had its collective short attention span been whittled down as ours has. In this image-glutted late-stage capitalist economy, we might lose hope that the true, the life-long, the hard-earned will preside over the vapid and the trends. But there is potential. In working with art, it’s essential that we look deeper at what the work is telling us – its visual qualities and conceptual thought – and how this might stand the test of time.


A good place to look is towards Pop Art: a key art movement to take mass consumerism as its subject. In January 1957, Richard Hamilton wrote to the architects Alison and Peter Smithson with a list of the qualities he saw in mass culture:


"Popular (designed for a mass audience)

Transient (short-term solution)

Expendable (easily-forgotten)

Low cost"


– Richard Hamilton, letter 16 January 1957


Today, it reads as a near-perfect description of an Instagram feed. Hamilton was writing in a war-weary, bomb-damaged Britain where rationing had ended only three years earlier, and the America he was describing – glossy, abundant, advertised – had arrived mostly as pictures. Such imagery was game-changing and unseen before. The artist Eduardo Paolozzi collected the magazines from discharged American GIs he met in Paris and cut them up. In 1952, at the first meeting of the Independent Group at the ICA, he projected them through an epidiascope: hundreds of images of cars, pin-ups, tinned food and appliances, flung at the wall one after another. It was there, through mass-imagery, that the first discussions of British Pop art took place – mass imagery that would become the subject of debate, philosophy and contemplation.


Andy Warhol, Marilyn Diptych (1962), acrylic on canvas © The Andy Warhol Foundation, Inc. Photo: rocor.
Andy Warhol, Marilyn Diptych (1962), acrylic on canvas © The Andy Warhol Foundation, Inc. Photo: rocor.

In America, Andy Warhol was early to this exploration. He had spent the fifties being paid to make advertisements which led onto his artistic practice. Campbell’s Soup Cans (1962), lines up thirty-two near-identical canvases like a shelf in a supermarket, each hand-painted. Warhol’s explanation? “I used to drink it. I used to have the same lunch every day, for 20 years, I guess, the same thing over and over again”.


The response was deceptively flat: the soup can could be seen as an argument about the capitalist system and what mass production does to human experience. Warhol held a mirror up to our face, and we saw something glossy, commercialised, and infinitely reproducible. Seventy years on, the digital successors of the billboards and shop windows of Pop art have annexed vast swathes of our mental bandwidth.


Cindy Sherman Instagram Portraits. Source
Cindy Sherman Instagram Portraits. Source

Some contemporary artists have ventured headlong into this with the same candour and wry self-awareness Pop did. Richard Prince’s New Portraits (2014) blew up strangers’ Instagram posts onto canvas and sold them for tens of thousands of dollars – the profile itself, framed and priced. Cindy Sherman, who built a career photographing invented women, playfully opened her Instagram in 2017 and filled it with grotesque self-parodic digital-age portraits, saturated faces pulled apart by beauty apps.






The Soup


Andy Warhol, Campbell's Soup Cans (1962), acrylic with metallic enamel paint on canvas
Andy Warhol, Campbell's Soup Cans (1962), acrylic with metallic enamel paint on canvas

Pop sought to get us thinking about the system and the proliferation of mass-made imagery. Warhol gave us thirty-two cans and hung them like a supermarket shelf. Ours never stops being restocked. Several million artists now post into the same aisle, where an algorithm decides what sits at eye level and it’s churned out so fast that the label is hardly read. Content is packaged and dished out to us to be slurped up and tossed away. Generative tools have joined the supply chain, adding an endless stock of finished-looking images that cost nothing to make and nothing to circulate. Every click leaves a cookie behind, and the machines follow the trail, serving our own appetites back to us until it all begins to taste the same. The shelf has never been fuller, and the taste never duller.


Many artists are turning towards self-representation. Saatchi Art, The Other Art Fair, Instagram – these are now where a lot of artwork goes to find a buyer, and for an artist without a gallery they may be the only option. The artist photographs the work, writes the description, picks a category and decides what it’s worth. There’s no dealer to disagree with the number, no record of past sales to measure it against, no show to put it in context. Just the artist and a price field.


Here is a small experiment. Open one of the large open marketplaces and sort the paintings by price, highest first. You might expect the top of that list to bring you the best names, or the most vetted and expert thinkers of our time. It does not. It is unfamiliar names and generic styles at numbers the artists have typed in themselves.



Screenshot (24th October 2026) Saatchi Art search engine: paintings, price: high to low
Screenshot (24th October 2026) Saatchi Art search engine: paintings, price: high to low

Sorting by price is standard on shopping sites. But it's a choice to build it into the website, and an incongruous one on a site selling art. Its very existence implies that price is tantamount to quality (it’s not). Are such websites truly capable of offering a refined and curated selection of artists, edited for quality? Of supporting an artist through a long career, or a buyer through a serious purchase? Perhaps, instead, they are geared towards offering as much quantity to the consumer as possible, regardless of artistic merit (see our previous article for more detail, The Quest for Originality in Art).


A price, properly arrived at, should be the residue of somebody’s judgement. When a gallery prices a show, it is pricing a career: where the artist trained, who has collected them, what the last body of work sold for, and what the next five, ten, twenty years ought to look like. Dealers routinely price below what the market would bear, to keep work out of the hands of people who will flip it. The numbers at the top of that search are none of this. At worst they mislead a buyer into paying for a craftsmanship that isn’t there, a judgement almost impossible to make through a 4:5 crop. Pricing without the discernment of an expert evaluator is but wishful arithmetic in the internet’s hall of mirrors.


More access is a good thing. The internet has given artists autonomy where galleries were closed to them, and it has let buyers in who were always put off by the velvet rope. But with easy access comes less intention, and without expert support we are choosing in the dark. The shelf is now so full that nobody can see past the front row. How do we learn to taste again?





Curatorship: Handle With Care


The word curator, as explored by Kyle Chayka in his 2024 book Filterworld, comes from the Roman curatores, the public officers who managed the upkeep of the city. Its root in latin is curare, to take care of; in Italian, curare is to heal. The term is cumulative by nature, built over two thousand years of use. And so, as Chayka puts it:



"Curation begins with responsibility"


– Kyle Chayka, Filterworld p. 249


The path of a curator is one of devotion. A curator is a steward, selecting work by weighing what the history of art has established against what the present is reaching for, and guiding artists towards pieces that hold a mirror up to our tastes, our interests, our sense of meaning. It takes a human who wants to create change: have us thinking, looking, responding. And it takes decades to do well. At Artelier we spend that time in artists’ studios and in conversation with the communities they belong to, scouring the world (often on the ground) – our database now holds 20,000 artists, each meticulously researched over decades – watching how a practice develops over years rather than how a single image performs on a screen. What we are assessing, in the end, is commitment.


Installation views, Documenta 11, Kassel, 2002. Left: Carlos Garaicoa, Campus or the Babel of Knowledge (2002). Centre: Yinka Shonibare, Gallantry and Criminal Conversation (2002). Right: Mona Hatoum, Homebound (2000). Photos: Haupt & Binder / universes.art
Installation views, Documenta 11, Kassel, 2002. Left: Carlos Garaicoa, Campus or the Babel of Knowledge (2002). Centre: Yinka Shonibare, Gallantry and Criminal Conversation (2002). Right: Mona Hatoum, Homebound (2000). Photos: Haupt & Binder / universes.art

Peggy Guggenheim with Jackson Pollock in front of Mural (1943), in the entrance hall of her New York townhouse, c. 1944.           Photo: Peggy Guggenheim Collection
Peggy Guggenheim with Jackson Pollock in front of Mural (1943), in the entrance hall of her New York townhouse, c. 1944. Photo: Peggy Guggenheim Collection

That is not to romanticise the old guard. It's important to recognise that for much of its history, curation could be gatekeeping, often a small, largely Western circle deciding who got in and who stayed out. It's taken many a brilliant mind to prise the canon open, such as Okwui Enwezor’s blockbuster Documenta 11 in 2002, where artists from Africa, Asia and Latin America were hung alongside the familiar Western names as equals, rather than representatives of a country as historically had been the case. Another example is Peggy Guggenheim, who upon discovering a young Jackson Pollock working as a janitor at her uncle's museum, signed him to a monthly stipend in 1943, which let him stop working as a custodian and paint full time. Such an act changed the direction of American art.


Today, it has been well documented in the art world that galleries are being forced into closure. In 2025, nearly sixty galleries closed worldwide, the most since 2008, and they were mostly the small and mid-sized spaces that give an artist a first show and a champion (ArtNet 2025).


Margaret Lovell, The Couple (1958), bronze
Margaret Lovell, The Couple (1958), bronze

Worryingly, the share buying work by a newly discovered artist fell from 66% to 45% in a single year (Art Basel UBS Survey 2026). In a tricky economic climate, buyers want to invest in solid names, and it is often the smaller galleries who advocate for and nurture emerging artists. Without their guidance, perhaps, buyers have less appetite for risk and adventure.


The cost falls hardest on the slowest work. Consider a cast bronze: weeks or months modelling in clay, then a mould taken from it, then a wax, then the firing, then molten metal poured at over a thousand degrees, and after that the welding, chasing, patination. Each and every stage done by hand, painstakingly, and none of it is reversible once the metal cools. Thousands of pounds are spent before a single buyer has seen it.


That expense buys something, though: bronze is among the most durable things a human being can make. Two figures holding each other, fixed in metal, will still be holding each other in four hundred years. Casting is costly enough that a modest artist can rarely build a body of work without a backer, which is precisely what a gallery used to be. What is being priced out, in other words, is not a material. It is the kind of time that outlasts us.





Being With Art & What We Can Do


It is worth remembering what we are protecting. Art’s essential force is its capacity to convey the human experience now and with all years past: it is the manifestation of the ineffable, of human evolution, love and suffering and all that lies beyond. Art has moved within the pull of the human spirit since the first pigment was dabbed onto a cave wall, and before that too. Appreciation of it is a deeply personal journey, and those who buy and curate it hold a real power – to invest in people who have given their lives to the work, and to own something that goes on giving back. Handing that over to machines, algorithms and robots is a great loss.


Not only that, but making is slow, and stubbornly so. A bronze goes to the foundry only after months of clay, and comes back weeks later, where it can’t be altered once cooled. Oil paint dries in slow time, hardening only when nature wills it. A painter waits for one layer before beginning the next, and may wait years before deciding it is finished: art grows with us. Whatever else has been disrupted, this has not been. The work takes the time it takes. What has changed is us.


An artist makes art because there is no other choice; it is a calling, as much as curating is. We all need to pay our bills, but, in the end, the path an artist walks is one we build for them – through the galleries we keep open, the work we buy, the expertise we pay for. It could be wider than it is. So as we widen access, we must also widen expertise. More voices means more ways of seeing that might change us.


What we can do about it is less grand than the problem suggests. Most galleries are free to enter. Having conversations about art is open to all. Meanwhile, Own Art, funded by the four UK arts councils, lends interest-free for work by living artists, and has done so more than eighty thousand times since 2004. Commissioning work puts an artist in a studio for months rather than minutes. And where there is real money at stake, a curator, or art advisor, is the oldest safeguard of art there is: somebody whose reputation depends on being right about the work.



In The End


"This is probably the secret: work for a long time and slowly".


– Vincent van Gogh, letter to Theo, Saint-Rémy, 5–6 September 1889


Van Gogh wrote that from the asylum garden, in the most productive year of his life. By then he had endured more than most: poverty, loneliness, illness, a reputation that reached truly very few people. The most celebrated artist in the world had, in his lifetime, no followers at all.


The recognition came, as we know: the museums, the millions, the sunflowers on postcards across Europe. But it came long after him, carried there by the few who loved the work enough to be patient with it – a brother who supported him financially and believed in him entirely, and a sister-in-law who inherited two hundred unsold canvases and spent thirty years placing them. Artistic justice, when it arrives, arrives slowly, and sometimes not in one lifetime at all.



Vincent Van Gogh, Irises (1889), oil on canvas
Vincent Van Gogh, Irises (1889), oil on canvas

Blue bruising to violet where the petals fold back, each bloom turned a different way, no two heads alike. Behind them, marigolds burning orange against red earth; an audience cradling the white iris that blooms apart from the rest, alone, alive and already going over. The leaves climb in long single strokes, following the direction of growth. And beneath it all the earth runs in short broken dashes, worked with the same restlessness as the flowers but outlasting their brief lives: the rhythm they rose out of and will return to. These are decisions, hundreds of them; a refuge, made in a hospital garden. None of them were made for a quick sale. They were made in the unyielding pursuit of an artist’s way of seeing, his way of being.


Art matters for more than the picture itself. It is a collective pursuit. The curator who holds both the artist’s vision and what we need from it, the galleries and buyers who keep the artist in materials and in the studio, the visitor who meets the work with presence: this is what carries it all forward. It's something an algorithm simply can't replace. Intention is human, and keeping it is slow work that no one person can do alone. That is the long, uncommercial, deliberate essence of art. Artists make work because it matters. Others lift it to the light. And a stranger stands in front of it and finds themselves, in that moment, taken care of.











 
 
Comments
Share Your ThoughtsBe the first to write a comment.

Offices

United Kingdom

154 Cheltenham Road, Bristol, BS6 5RL, UK

Barcelona 

Rambla de Catalunya 38, 8º, 1ª, 08007 Barcelona, Spain

Client Offices - Appointment Only

London

64 Grosvenor Street

Mayfair, UK

Dubai 

739 Sheikh Zayed Road

Dubai, United Arab Emirates

Contact Us

Linkedin Logo on Artelier website

Hong Kong

21/F, New World Tower I, 16-18 Queen's Road Central, Hong Kong

© Copyright

© Artelier 2026

bottom of page